Reuters - 9/29/2022 3:51:46 PM - GMT (+4 )
As grocery bills soar, hungry Brazilians may seal Bolsonaro’s fate
By Amanda Perobelli, Adriano Machado, Ueslei Marcelino, Pilar Olivares and Diego Vara
Reporting by Lisandra Paraguassu
Filed September 29, 2022, 11:00 a.m. GMT
The specter of hunger hangs over Brazil's presidential race this year like few before it.
Rampant inflation and fallout from the pandemic have pushed food insecurity here to levels nearly unrecognizable a decade ago. One in three Brazilians say they have struggled recently to feed their families.
Trailing in the polls and eager to offer relief, President Jair Bolsonaro dribbled budget rules to boost Brazil's main welfare program by 50% through the end of the year.
But that has failed to move the needle so far. Opinion surveys show his support among the poorest Brazilians flat or flagging since the more generous payouts started.
Welfare recipients interviewed by Reuters in a half dozen states were reluctant to give Bolsonaro credit for the expiring election-year benefits. Most said they are pulling for his left-wing rival, former President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who slashed hunger and extreme poverty with the help of a commodity boom during his 2003-2010 presidency.
In the slums of Brazilian cities, families are struggling to feed themselves as hunger rises in the powerhouse food exporter.
"We're the forgotten ones. There is no lunch today," says Dona Monica in a "favela" called Arco Iris (Rainbow) on a river smelling of sewers and urine in the northeastern city of Recife where dengue is rife.
In the center of Sao Paulo, Brazil's largest city, Carla Marquez lives in a room paid for by a church with her husband Carlos Henrique Mendes, 25, and 5-year-old daughter. "We haven't bought food in ages. Prices are absurdly high. I've nothing to give her," the 36-year old mother said in tears.
Carla Marquez, 36, who is six months pregnant, cries as she talks about gas and food prices in the room where she and her family live in Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 11, 2022. REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
Marquez shows her daughter, Gabriela, 5, ultrasound images in the room where they live in Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 15, 2022. REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
Carlos Henrique Mendes, 25, (2nd R) his wife, Marquez, (C) and their daughter, Gabriela, (2nd L) eat a meal they cooked on a wood fire in the street in Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 16, 2022. REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
Marquez holds a bowl containing rice, beans and eggs, a meal that she and her husband cooked on a fire in the street, in Sao Paulo, Brazil September 16, 2022. REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
Marquez and her daughter Gabriela sit in the doorway of the room where they live, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, September 15, 2022.REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
U.N. HUNGER MAP
Brazil's election looks to be yet another case of soaring global food inflation unsettling incumbents, but hunger has been mounting a comeback in Latin America's largest economy for the better part of a decade.
Just eight years ago, Brazil hit its U.N. target for eliminating widespread malnourishment ahead of schedule. Since then, the share of Brazilians who say they cannot feed their families in the past 12 months has more than doubled to 36%, according to the Getulio Vargas Foundation (FGV) think tank.
The result is a consensus across Brazil's political establishment that the country needs a stronger social safety net. Almost every major party and candidate has backed 'emergency' cash stipends to 20 million families, which benefit roughly one in four Brazilians – making it one of the world's most far-reaching welfare programs.
FGV's Marcelo Neri says he has never seen hunger so central to the electoral debate.
"The whole political spectrum is talking about food insecurity, the emphasis is everywhere," he said.
Bolsonaro and Lula both promise they will work to extend this year's more generous welfare program or even expand it. Neither has explained how they would fund this – but analysts reckon it will mean the end of a constitutional spending limit that has defined fiscal policy for the past six years.
LULA LEADING RACE
Voter opinion polls show that Bolsonaro did manage to narrow Lula's advantage earlier this year by increasing Auxilio Brasil and working to lower fuel costs, but Lula has begun to pull away again in the last two weeks.
Lula's polling lead widened to 17 percentage points in a survey by pollster IPEC published on Monday, ahead of Sunday's first-round vote, with 48% of voter support to 31% for Bolsonaro. The poll showed Lula could win outright, with 52% of voter intentions excluding abstentions and null votes.
If the race goes to a second-round runoff, Lula would win by 54% of the votes versus Bolsonaro's 35%, according to the IPEC poll, which had a margin of error of 2 percentage points.
"The aid has not generated the effect the government had expected. The increase was seen by people as an electoral maneuver and they are rejecting the ploy," pollster Felipe Nunes, of Quaest Pesquisa e Consultoria, told Reuters.
FGV economist Neri agreed Lula's credibility is higher among Brazil's poor, because Bolsonaro's social welfare measures have been erratic. The government reduced and then suspended emergency aid after the COVID-19 pandemic, and when welfare was restored it was at a lower value, he said.
Meanwhile, food prices have continued to go up, driven up by fuel and transport costs, and have risen 9.83% in the year.
"People say Bolsonaro is helping. But he gives and then takes it away. It was much better with Lula," said Luciana Messias dos Santos, 29.
In her wooden shack in Estrutural, Brasilia's largest favela, she had to adapt her stove to cook with wood as fuel because gas is too expensive.
Bolsonaro has denied hunger has become critical in Brazil, irritated by the importance given to the hunger issue has taken on in the election campaign.
"Hunger in Brazil? It does not exist the way it is being reported," he said in August. Last week, his Economy Minister, Paulo Guedes, took on a survey by the Penssan Network that said 33 million people face starvation. "It's a lie. That is false. These are not the numbers," he said.
In Rio de Janeiro, welfare recipient Carla Feliciano, 38, says she survives picking fruit and vegetables from dumpsters outside the municipal market. She said life has gotten very difficult after the pandemic under the Bolsonaro government.
"Welfare or no welfare makes no difference. I vote for Lula. I will die a Lula supporter," she said.
WELFARE AS ELECTION PLOY
Average income of poor Brazilians has fallen to levels of 10 years ago, widening the country's stark social inequality.
Bolsonaro has focused on winning their votes he needs to be re-elected, an uphill task running against Lula, whose conditional cash-transfer welfare program called Bolsa Familia lifted millions from poverty when he was in office.
Bolsonaro renamed the program Auxilio Brasil to end the association of social welfare with Lula, but this has not brought the electoral dividends he had hoped for.
"Bolsonaro has tried to play this card, but it won't help him," said Carla's husband Carlos, who scrapes by collecting scrap cardboard in the streets of Sao Paulo. He said he will vote for Lula and his Workers Party. His wife is not so sure.
Living in a tent with her children and grandchildren just half a mile from the presidential place in Brasilia, Edilene Alves, says she sees through Bolsonaro's ploy.
The distrust of Bolsonaro's motives held by Carlos and Edilene was echoed by low-income Brazilians from Porto Alegre in the deep south to Salvador and Recife in the northeast.
"They think we are dumb. Increasing welfare from 400 reais ($76.05) to 600 reais does not help when supermarket prices have risen so much," said the migrant from Brazil's poor Northeast. "People are going to die of hunger."
A boy and girl swing from a tree on a tire under a polluted channel of water and sewage in Recife, Brazil September 13, 2022. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino
Carla carries a box of fruit and vegetables donated by merchants at the CEASA supply centre in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, August 30, 2022. REUTERS/Pilar Olivares
Carla, (C) sorts through food that has been thrown out to find edible products to cook with at the CEASA supply centre, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, August 29, 2022. REUTERS/Pilar Olivares
Carla sorts through food that has been thrown out to find edible products to cook with at the CEASA supply centre, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, August 29, 2022.REUTERS/Pilar Olivares
Elvira (L) and her sons Marcio (C) and Yuri (R) collect garbage in Porto Alegre, Brazil, September 1, 2022. REUTERS/Diego Vara
Luciana stands in front her home with her son, in the Estrutural favela in Brasilia, Brazil, August 31, 2022. REUTERS/Adriano Machado
Luciana Messias dos Santos, 29, walks with her children to fetch water, near their home in the Estrutural favela in Brasilia, Brazil, September 1, 2022. REUTERS/Adriano Machado
Thawanny drinks water in front of the fridge, after lunch in her family's house, in the Arco Iris favela in Recife, Brazil, September 15, 2022. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino
Thawanny and Yago Silva de Souza, 2, eat a lunch of rice, beans and egg at their family's house in the Arco Iris favela in Recife, Brazil, September 15, 2022. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino
River dwellings known as palafitte or "Palafita" are seen in Recife, Brazil, September 13, 2022. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino
A child walks next a shack on squatted land in front of the National Congress in Brasilia, Brazil, August 29, 2022. RREUTERS/Adriano Machado
The Wider Image
Photography: Amanda Perobelli, Adriano Machado, Ueslei Marcelino, Pilar Olivares and Diego Vara
Reporting: Lisandra Paraguassu
Additional Reporting: Ueslei Marcelino and Pilar Olivares
Writing: Anthony Boadle
Photo editing: Kezia Levitas
Text Editing: Diane Craft
Design: Kezia Levitas